The Destruction of a Dawn Redwood Tree
I had intended that my next blog post would be about my summer meanderings, however, two days ago, something happened that shocked me.
I’ll start back at last Tuesday. Several neighbours and I went to a council planning meeting to hear the verdict on a building proposal. The developer was proposing to replace the house on a nearby plot with two new houses. The proposal also included landscaping of the garden. ‘Landscaping’ apparently meant the removal of 22 out of 28 trees.
The house hasn’t been lived in for several years and was rather overgrown, so obviously, some clearance was necessary. However on the boundary between that house and our next door neighbour’s was a magnificent Dawn Redwood tree. Although Dawn Redwoods are endangered, they are not protected (find out more here).
Each year since we’ve lived in this house, I’ve watched the needles change from green to brown in the autumn and when the early morning sun lit it up, they glowed like copper. The plot is elevated above many of the neighbouring houses and since it was such a tall tree, most of the neighbours in our area could see it too. The lady who’d lived in the house must have planted it because she and her husband had been the people who’d built the house. Before that, I believe the area was an orchard. She once told me that experts from Kew Gardens had come to look at the tree and had said it was the largest specimen in Europe. It was a truly magnificent tree.
At the council meeting the proposal to build the two houses and carry out the landscaping was turned down, although it was very close. Seven votes to reject the proposal and 6 to allow it. Strangely, the six members who voted to allow the proposal didn’t speak up in defence of their opinions although they were encouraged to do so on several occasions by the chair. Indeed, one of the six had earlier given a good reason why it was not a good proposal to accept. Nevertheless, he still voted to allow it.
During the meeting somebody from the planning office said that the trees weren’t the issue regarding privacy, after all there were no tree preservation orders (TPOs) on any of the trees and the developer could go in the following day and knock them all down. She said that privacy should be achieved by design. That’s quite a task since the existing house is much higher than the houses around it. With no trees providing screening, it is bound to look out on them.
A planning officer came around several weeks ago when the first planning proposal had been submitted by the developer for three houses on the plot (that was later rejected), and she told us that the council tree expert had decided the redwood tree was too large and would have to be chopped down. Although we’d considered trying to get a TPO on the tree, there didn’t seem to be much point if we would have to apply to a man who had already decided it needed to be cut down. We learnt at the meeting that the council tree expert had been advised by the developer’s tree expert. So, we might have stood a chance of getting a TPO if we’d tried. Of course, the following morning, the first thing we did was to start the process of getting a TPO on the tree. Little did we suspect there’d be no time. We hoped that common sense would prevail. After the success on Tuesday, we imagined that the developer would submit new plans and that sooner or later the existing house would be demolished and more houses built. However, we were only really worried about the trees, the privacy they offered and particularly the redwood which everyone loved.
On Friday morning, the developer arrived with tree surgeons who were going to clear the area. And guess which tree they made for first? Yes the magnificent Dawn Redwood tree.



The neighbours couldn’t believe it. For most of Friday, chainsaws were going as they lopped off branches until it looked like a totem pole and then I brought the whole thing down with such a crash that it shook our house. In fact, I thought the tree had fallen the wrong way and hit our side wall.
The tree surgeons will be back on Monday to clear more. I cannot believe that such a wonderful tree has been destroyed. The plot is directly opposite a primary school. What sort of message are we sending those children? We talk about preserving trees and valuing biodiversity and then we do exactly as we please with our environment.
If the Dawn Redwood had been in the way, I would’ve understood it, but it was on the boundary. It had been there all the time the previous owner had lived there.
And now it is gone. Each time I look out of the window all I can see is sky. Next week I’ll be able to clearly see the house next door for the first time ever if they clear as much of the remaining trees as I suspect they will.
Friday was a sad day.
So, the moral of the story is that if you have trees near you that you enjoy, even if they’re not yours, consider applying to your council for a TPO. Apparently you don’t need to own the tree to do that. One day, someone might appear with a chainsaw and simply remove it, so if you value it and would miss it if it disappeared, apply immediately. It takes many weeks before one might be granted, so don’t delay.
